DAILY NEWS Jun 21, 2010 4:54 PM - 7 comments

Home and Garden TV and Home Depot cited as "culprits" in the escalation of water damage claims

TEXT SIZE bigger text smaller text

Home and Garden Television (HGTV) and Home Depot are two main culprits responsible for the escalation of water damage claims costs, according to Will Cook, president of Belfor Restoration Services.
These two cultural icons are fuelling the impulse to undertake an "extreme home makeover," encouraging so-called "weekend warriors" to transform their modest, 2,200-square-foot homes into 8,000-quare-foot estates, Cook observed.
Cook's presentation at the Insurance Brokers Association of B.C. (IBABC)'s 62nd Annual Conference and Trade Show in Victoria focused on explaining the escalation of water damage loss values.
"We now have 24-7 home improvement television," Cook observed. "(HGTV) host Sarah Richardson tells you that if you don't have an architecturally-decorated basement, you're not cool, you're not chic, you're not with the times.
"So Home and Garden TV is putting a tremendous amount of upward pressure on us to beautify our homes."
Home Depot enables this kind of home renovation, Cook said.
"In 1994, Home Depot incorporated in Canada," he said. "They now have revenues in excess of $60 billion in a 16-year life span.
"They enable the ‘weekend warriors,' the people that Sarah Richardson is telling to beautify their homes."
Laminate flooring is yet another culprit in the escalation of insurers' water damage claims, Cook said. And upon saying this, panel moderator Kevin McIntyre, past president of IBABC, chimed in: "Laminate is Latin for ‘crap.'"
Cook noted laminate flooring is popular in finished basements because it is scratch-resistant, does not release allergenic material and is easy to clean. "Its only known enemy is water," he added.
Unlike hardwood, laminate does not return back to its normal shape after it has absorbed water; instead, it remains swelled. And fixing it often requires the removal of baseboards and moldings, thus escalating the costs to make repairs.
As a result, an unfinished basement, which did not require much clean-up after water damage, costs about $1,400 to fully dehumidify and repair. Laminated, a similar-sized finished basement now costs about $7,500 to repair and dehumidify, Cook said.



Horizontal ruler

Reader Comments

Most recent firstOldest first

John from Toronto

I watch this show all the time The worst I see is Carter Can, They paint over switch cover plates and duplex cover plates all the time. later when you try to remove the covers the cover sticks to the drywall and tears the paper backing. Also they showed a show where he closed in the refridgerator and did not leave it room to get rid of the heat. This would make the fridge work a lot harder to cool the unit and a waist of electricity. Also some of the joints in his projects do not fit very well. I have done repairs for years. I think the show should have a consultant look at his projects.

Posted August 17, 2010 01:49 PM


M. CHIN

I agree with K. Kimko. Joe Smith's post that insurance premiums should account for water damage to finished basement, appears to be from a textbook point of view but only works in theory if the homeowner discloses the increased value after a renovation , but they never do.

Posted June 25, 2010 08:21 AM


Lorraine Bergman

The fault lies with the weekend warriors who spend their renovation dollars on the esthetics before the basics, like replacing the old hot water tank and changing up the plastic for the braided steel hoses. Not to mention, doing the work themselves when it calls for a tradesman and a permit! Insurers must get tougher on new submissions and either exclude water damage losses unless there is confirmation of updating by a qualified person or apply much larger deductibles....there really is an epidemic of water losses and so many, preventable!

Posted June 23, 2010 04:41 PM


K Klimko

Although Joe says the insured will increase their insurance to cover the renovation this very rarely occurs as the "weekend warrior" often does not even think about their insurance coverage until the bill/invoice comes in and then very often just renews as sent. They do not tell their broker of any changes that have been done to the home so the Insurer does nt get the "additional premium".

Posted June 22, 2010 04:52 PM


Andrew Hernandez

There is no question that some modern materials and designs have driven up the cost of home repairs. As Will Cook points out, it is not just a question of more costly materials, which can be covered by charging more premium, the extent of damage is sometimes also magnified. Using the example of water damage to laminate, whereas in the past drying and cleaning/re-polishing might have addressed damage to flooring, laminate requires a complete tear out and re-install. There is no such thing as a partial repair anymore.

Posted June 22, 2010 12:51 PM


FirstPrevNextLast
Horizontal Ruler

Post A Comment

Disclaimer
Note: By submitting your comments you acknowledge that Canadian Underwriter has the right to reproduce, broadcast and publicize those comments or any part thereof in any manner whatsoever. Please note that due to the volume of e-mails we receive, not all comments will be published and those that are published will not be edited. However, all will be carefully read, considered and appreciated.

Your Name (this will appear with your post) *

Email Address (will not be published) *

Comments *



* mandatory fields