Canadian Underwriter

ICBC board finalizes terms of reference for independent review of insurance rates

January 26, 2017   by Canadian Underwriter

Print this page Share

The Insurance Corporation of British Columbia’s (ICBC) Board of Directors (BoD) has finalized the terms of reference for an independent review of the fairness and affordability of basic insurance rates in the province, with the idea being to limit future increases to the rate of inflation.

Further, “an Expression of Interest seeking an independent third party expert has been posted on BCBid,” Barry Penner, chair of ICBC’s BoD, said in a statement Thursday.

Benner’s announcement follows a directive issued last December by Todd Stone, provincial transportation and infrastructure minister, who is also responsible for ICBC.

At the time, Stone directed ICBC to commission a comprehensive, independent third-party review to explore a range of options and make recommendations that will “keep insurance rates affordable and align future rate increases with inflation.”

Said Stone, “Our goal with this review is to put British Columbians first and for ICBC to manage its cost pressures, ensuring affordable rates for the long term.”

Related: B.C. directs ICBC to conduct review of insurance rates, approve Basic rate increase of no more than 4.9%

“Rapidly increasing numbers of crashes, claims and claims costs are putting significant pressure on the cost of insurance in British Columbia – pressures shared across the auto insurance industry in North America,” notes the ICBC statement Thursday.

It has been reported that between mid-2015 to mid-2016, for example, the number of vehicle damage claims increased by 11% and the number of injury claims increased by 14%. The average cost of vehicle claims is also on the rise, up 17% between 2014 and 2015, as vehicles become more expensive to repair and injury claim costs rise.

The BoD’s plan is to have the third party selected and the review started by mid-March, and to submit a preliminary report in June to “inform ICBC’s August basic rate filing with the British Columbia Utilities Commission (BCUC),” the insurer reports.

Based on the principles of maintaining public ownership of ICBC and operating under the current model, ICBC points out, “the review will identify key factors impacting basic insurance rates and provide a broad range of options available to limit future basic rate increases to the rate of inflation.”

The BoD has retained Gord Macatee, current commissioner of BC Ferries, who has considerable public sector experience, to advise board members and provide insights over the course of the review.

Related: ICBC identifies over 3,000 possible fraud alerts on open claims with new analytics software

While the review is under way, ICBC reports both it and the provincial government will continue to work together to mitigate rate pressure. Measures include the following:

  • focusing on stopping fraudulent and exaggerated claims;
  • doubling the basic premiums on certain high-value vehicles (personal vehicles worth more than $150,000) so the average ratepayer is not covering the cost of repairing those expensive, luxury cars;
  • government directing ICBC to transfer money from the optional side of its business to our basic business to help keep rates low; and
  • government foregoing any dividend from ICBC for at least three years.

The province’s Ministry of Transportation and Infrastructure also noted last December that the province had issued a directive to the BCUC to approve a basic rate increase of a maximum of 4.9% or less by Jan. 16, 2017.

Related: ICBC asks for 4.9% increase to basic insurance rates, lower than last year’s 5.5% increase

Print this page Share

4 Comments » for ICBC board finalizes terms of reference for independent review of insurance rates
  1. dirty says:

    Hopefully the independent review recommends abolishing ICBC and going private! Of course costs are continuing to rise when ICBC insurers are suing other ICBC insurers! The system is milking itself for payouts! A private system where insurance companies actually try to REDUCE payouts is the only way to have any kind of oversight.

    • Jay says:

      You have an idea here dirty . It is obviously mismanaged – EVEN with a captive market that companies would duel over . The leadership team has let down the drivers of BC this is clear and undisputed , BUT has continued to cash big bonus checks. hmmmm yes, selling the whole enchilada would pay down debt , and make available a huge tax pool for the BC government /people to tax . The NEW industry would have to be highly regulated…. but it already is , isn’t it . Good point dirty … just needs some details to make it work. These SAME people that run the Corp now , WILL run it to the grounds, if past predicts the future , or they will reduce benefits to near zero while keeping your premiums high ! 389 managers / Sups at ICBC earning over 80K +++ per year cant help ? Its is time to show them the door …..QUICK … IF you want to save ICBC. Tough love NOW !

  2. Donald Wood says:

    if the constabulary issued tickets for driving infractions, ICBC would not need to increase premiums. nobody in BC gets a ticket for bad driving habits. all remittances for driving infractions go to ICBC. while the cats away…the mice will play…duhh!!

  3. Jay says:

    …so your saying to have an “icbc police” ? dont like that idea ! do you know they ( ICBC) already gives the police millions and millions to do policing work it should be doing in the first place ? ? Kind of blurs the insurer and state divisions huh ?

Have your say:

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *