Canadian Underwriter
News

Drivers with fewer than four hours’ sleep had 11.5 times the crash rate of those who slept seven hours or more: AAA


December 9, 2016   by Canadian Underwriter


Print this page

There is a “significantly elevated” risk of a collision if a driver has slept for fewer than seven hours in the previous 24, the AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety concluded in a recent report.

Sleepy driverThe Washington, D.C.-based AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety released Dec. 6 a study in which it analyzed more than 4,500 collisions that occurred in the United States about 10 years ago.

“The estimated crash risk associated with driving after only 4-5 hours of sleep compared with 7 hours or more” is similar to the U.S. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration’s “estimated of crash risk” associated with driving with blood alcohol level of .08% “or slightly over,” AAA suggested in the report.

“Symptoms of drowsy driving can include having trouble keeping eyes open, drifting from lanes or not remembering the last few miles driven,” AAA stated in a release. “However, more than half of drivers involved in fatigue-related crashes experienced no symptoms before falling asleep behind the wheel.”

The report, Acute Sleep Deprivation and Risk of Motor Vehicle Crash Involvement, was written by AAA Foundation For Traffic Safety senior research associate Brian Tefft. The foundation analyzed data from the NHTSA National Motor Vehicle Crash Causation Survey (NMVCCS), “which comprised a representative sample of police-reported crashes that occurred between July 2005 and December 2007.”

Those crashes occurred between 6:00 a.m. and midnight and involved at least one car, pickup truck, van, minivan or sport utility vehicle. In all crashes, emergency medical services responded. The collisions were subject to investigations – independent of law enforcement – as part of a special study by the U.S. Department of Transportation. The final sample was of 7,234 drivers in 4,571 crashes.

The results “indicate that there is a significantly elevated crash risk” for drivers who slept for less than seven hours in the previous 24, the foundation said in the report. There is also a higher risk of collision when drivers sleep for one or more hours less than they usually sleep, independent of how much they usually sleep.

Compared to drivers who slept at least seven hours in the past 24, drivers who reported six to seven hours had 1.3 times the crash rate. Drivers who had between five and six hours had 1.9 times the crash rate. Drivers who slept four to five hours had 4.3 times the crash rate. Drivers who had less than four hours had 11.5 times the crash rate.

The risk associated with having fewer than four hours of sleep in the past 24 is comparable to the risk associated with having a blood alcohol level of 0.12% to 0.15%, the AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety reported.

The independent investigations of the collisions surveyed “included an assessment of factors that contributed to the crash (errors committed by drivers vehicle mechanical failures, environmental conditions) as well as an assessment of how many hours the driver had slept in the 24 hours before the crash, usually daily amount of sleep, and whether the driver had changed their sleep schedule recently.”

The data on sleep was self-reported, according to the report. That data, in some cases, “may have been inaccurate due to errors in drivers’ memories of recent sleep or due to deliberate misreporting,” the foundation stated. “For example, drivers might have over-reported their sleep to avoid admitting to having committed a behaviour that might be regarded as negligent.”

Sixteen drivers in the survey “reported not having slept at all in the 24 hours before the crash, indicating that some drivers were willing to report extreme levels of sleep deprivation.”

Drivers who reported they had slept four or more hours less than their usual amount had 10.2 times the crash rate as those who did have their usual amount of sleep, according to the report. Drivers who reported having slept three to four hours less than their usual amount had 2.1 times the crash rate; drivers who reported having slept two to three hours less than their usual amount had three times the crash rate; and drivers who reported having slept an hour or two less than their usual amount had 1.3 times the crash rate.